Thursday, 7 May 2015

Where is Education in the British Election?



As the British election campaign draws to a close,  the political parties are making their final passionate pleas to the electorate.  In the era of ‘retail offer politics’, the election debate has been dominated by last minute offers and overshadowed by the myriad of speculation surrounding combinations for coalition.  Notable in its absence has been any great discourse around the area of education, particularly with the ghost of Tony Blair's three word mantra still ringing in many ears.

In this, it can be argued that the politicians are led by the public.  Numerous polling on the ‘issues of greatest concern to the electorate’ produce the same list of concerns.  Immigration, the NHS, The Economy dominate with education a relatively distant fourth according to the latest Ipsos Mori poll conducted with the Economist. (April 30th)

It has been notable that the areas of debate that have featured education have often subsumed it into other headline areas of concern.  The number of school places are discussed, but in the open debates and discussion programmes that have come to characterise this campaign, the conversation quickly becomes more about immigration than education.  This is reflected in the headline policies of the parties, particularly those on the right.

The Conservative Party, still likely to poll the largest number of seats has made its flagship policy one of expansion and deregulatory philosophy.  ‘Free schools, funded by the state but run by parents, teachers or third parties outside council control.’ (Telegraph Newspaper, 2nd May 2015) At least 500 extra free schools will be built if the Conservatives win the election, David Cameron has said, in addition to promises about the number of apprenticeships, something largely subsumed into the debate on employment and benefit culture.

Free schools have a level of freedom to set their own curriculum and employ teachers without formal teaching qualifications – something that Labour Shadow Education Minister Tristram Hunt tried and failed to make a key debate issue from.  The argument of the danger of ‘unqualified people teaching our kids’ struggled to gain any real traction, largely because most voters older than 30 were more than likely themselves taught by unqualified teachers, including senior figures in all political parties.

Labour’s headline education policy is simple.  The party supports a one third decrease in tuition fees, from a capped maximum of £9,000 per year to £6000.  On paper this should be an effective policy, however, public trust in declarations around University tuition is at an all time low after the Liberal Democrat pledge of the 2010 election.  This broken promise is, according to the latest polling, set to be a defining factor in a two thirds reduction in seats for the party.

The fallout of this has understandably made the Liberal Democrats extremely reticent to discuss education at all and brought a note of caution to the promises of all the major parties.  The Liberal Democrats have shifted their focus away from the disaffected student to parents of the youngest children, proposing ‘15 hours free early education to all three-to-four year-olds and 40 per cent of two-year-olds.’ They have also aimed policies at building a stronger link between investment per pupil and need, encouraging higher spending in the most deprived areas.

Indeed, all three major parties have made promises around departmental spending and this has characterised the second half of the debate regarding protected investment as each party tries to avoid being forced to list the areas where spending cuts are set to fall.  No party has made education a protected area, meaning that the national education budget will face decreases in the coming five year term.  Lack of funds, increasingly entrenched and ‘blue sky policy’ weary teacher’s unions provide another obstacle to big policy change, as discovered by the ignominious reshuffling last year of Conservative Education Minister Michael Gove, in spite of broad public support for his reforms.

Perhaps the greatest reason why education is not leading the election as an issue in comparison to previous years is this – meaningful policy change in relation to education is an investment issue, a long term commitment from which the results might not be seen for a generation of pupils.  In an election as close and increasingly bitter as this one, it could be argued that the long term vision is being sacrificed for the short term political soundbyte, the ‘retail offer’ designed to move that last undecided voter.

Issues of national statistical interest, such as Britain’s fluctuating position in the various league tables are less likely to drive voters who are being encouraged from all sides to appeal to their own self interest in their political choice.  Because of this, whoever wins tonight, education in the United Kingdom faces an uncertain future.



Tuesday, 20 January 2015

Charlie and the man in the street


In approaching this post, circumstance has perhaps done me a favour.  My educational consultancy work based in Paris was at its apex when the events unfolded there and our deadlines prohibited me from the blog response I wanted to make - most likely an impassioned defence of liberty and freedom of speech, a voice amongst the many spurred on by fear for and love of my colleagues in Paris and my journalistic instincts from years as a writer and satirist of many things, including religion.

I was not able to make that response, and as a result, I have been forced to think. My anger has cooled... the media blitz has waned and something tells me that now might be the time to speak with what passes for a clear head these days. The demonstrations in Paris and around the world made the hair on the back of my neck stand on end. As the only British partner in a French company, I know the power of the French passion, to us an almost child-like intensity with which they feel and unleash emotion.  I would put this on a list (along with gastronomy and sex) of things they do better than us.

In a world where nationalism is perceived as an almost ugly, slightly barbaric mentality, its outpouring, even in the name of values we share, even in the name of Charlie, or Ahmed, or unity or love will be treated with caution, or even trepidation by those who do not perceive that those values are theirs to share in.  I know this, because that trepidation has been voiced by those closest to me, who maintain the almost unbreakable sense of vulnerability through 'otherness', whether it be in their religion, their race, or the colour of their skin.  This otherness, unlike these attacks has little to do with Islam save that it is one of its many facets.

This is an uncertain or even frightening time to be 'other'.  In France, the far right is polling at historical levels.  The history of the last few decades has been that when faced with Le Pen as a realistic possibility, the people of France have come together, from the moderate left and right, and blocked a chance at a victory for the Front National.  I have every faith that this will happen again, but there is no mistaking the sentiment and
for me, not enough serious questioning of what drives it.

Perhaps the ultimate price of empire, both in Britain and France will prove to be a moral inability to claim exclusivity to our cultural identity. We traversed the globe when it seemed larger.  Far off lands were truly far off.  We acted and prospered in our own nationalistic interest. And now, the globalisation of our national soul is something that we struggle to rationalise, to discuss or in the case of our politicians, to manage as those children of the empire come to us - Children upon whose shores we landed as well armed migrants possessed of a clinical, at times deadly ideology of nationalism, colonisation and even slavery.

"What does this mean for Britain?"  Every media outlet has been quick to invite parallels, to draw comparisons, to envisage a "Paris style attack" in London, or a full scale invasion which according to CNN will be launched from the Islamic Republic of Birmingham. Perhaps the more pressing question is more complex. I want to ask it.

"Is it right to wish to preserve a sense of national identity that is founded on exclusive ideas?" In this I would include a Judeo Christian underpinning to a broadly secular society.  Should this be fought for, spoken for, preserved either in law or even as a moral principle?  Is it even possible to do these things when growing numbers of people born in this country hold ideologies that are alien to the 'green and pleasant' idyl of UKIP and the people tempted to vote for them.  Unlike in science fiction, alien does not have to mean hostile, but differences couched in faith, when politicised can only lead to conflict. Politicised Islam invites the rebuttal that this is a 'Christian country'. (One religion with alien origins rejects another)

So what is the answer?  Is it numerical?  Is there a magic number of people of 'different' colour, accent or faith that a society can absorb, integrate and sustain before the fear of 'otherness' is felt by those who would consider themselves indigenous. (An elegant word when used about woodland birdlife - an ugly loaded one when used about people)  Whom should we listen to?  The politicians? The minorities themselves?  Can they adapt to all this freedom?  Should they adapt and if they can't should they 'go back to their own countries', (Even if that does mean Birmingham)  It seems that politicians look in small part to minority groups to say the right things. (The MCB has not covered itself in glory this week) Is there an unspoken price to be paid as a migrant or the child of one. The sense that no matter what you do, the British or French society will never truly accept you or belong to you to the same extent as it does to those who look and speak and pray like the majority, no matter how liberal that society claims to be? No government would dare say this even if the hard logic of it is difficult to dispute.  For their majority view, they look to, and speak of and act on behalf of 'The man in the street.'

The man in the street, or as the chill of winter sets in, the man in the pub is a man whose opinions come from the things he has witnessed in the street, or watched on the news, fed by a media that tailors its content to his reading level and attention span. The man in the street is not one for long conversations.  He is someone who believes there is a simple answer to every problem.  The man in the street seems to be able to use the phrase 'I'm not racist but...' without tasting the irony in his gut.  The man in the street is selfish.  Even if he doesn't enjoy his own circumstances, he does not wish them to change.  The man in the street has been taught to fear the alien, to distrust bureaucratic europeans, scrounging migrants, Muslims who will 'impose Sharia law' on him.

It is a shame of our democracy and an utter failure of political and intellectual courage that the man in the street must be pandered to, in words politicians believe he understands - words designed to enforce his gut feelings and give him the sense that 'something must be done.'  The man in the street is being played, and even if he suspects this, he has no option, no recourse.  Everyone has come to him - put on his ill fitting clothes and tried to convince him that they think his views are important.  The man in the street has two choices.  he can withdraw his vote - give in to apathy or he can send a message by voting for the party that has least shame in pretending to be him.

The man in the street is not Charlie.  I am not Charlie.  Before the attacks, Charlie was fighting for its market share, smothered by the self censorship of mainstream media, cornered by its own politics under the weight of this broken bovine conspiracy of consensus of what one does not say. My personal belief is that at times, this pushed Charlie beyond common sense.  A lone voice, fighting a tide will always raise that voice and occasionally lose the focus of its words in the process. This is a human failing, one that should be understood.  The Charlies of this world are braver than me and have a greater stake in their society than the man on the street.  The Charlies of the world do not keep quiet, regulate their content out of fear of the letter of complaint, the online questionnaire or even the death rattle of an AK47.  Charlie's murdered journalists were victims of an ideology that is well funded, growing in influence and achieving success on the complicated and neglected battlefields of Syria and Nigeria, and in the faltering revolution of Libya. We should not underestimate the scale of the threat of this ideology.  It cannot be reasoned with or rationalised, something it shares not just with its parent religion of wider Islam, but with all religions.  In that, the battle is philosophical.  You cannot treat with it, give it concessions.  There are none that could satisfy it, even with the removal of Israel from the map or the banning of all criticism of Islam. Intolerance does not thank you for your tolerance.  It seeks to undermine it.

Perhaps then, it is the undesired duty of a largely secular Britain to become a nation of armchair theologists. Time and again, we are told that extremist attacks have 'nothing to do with Islam', by people that one suspects have at best, a rudimentary grasp of this major world religion. Whilst this argument is semantically flawed in a way that is both obvious and infuriating, the message behind it... (Don't let this be an excuse to take your new found righteous anger out on any vaguely brown person wearing a scarf) is one that should be listened to, and perhaps, communicated in a less patronising form. Perhaps this could be a starting point for something vital.  Britain, and British society must build a relationship with Islam. To do this, we may need our abandoned, shamed sense of nationalism to create a vibrant, generous, spiritual and perhaps, uniquely British version of the faith that gives ownership to those who would not advocate suffering on anyone for an expression of their belief, or lack thereof. This is not a new idea, and to achieve it, there will need to be give on both sides. It will take a generation to achieve and there will likely be pain along the road to achieving it.

Nationalism does not have to be an identity built on the foundations of a past.  English nationalism in particular has found this problematic. We need a nationalism of the future - One that is honest about its past and does not seek to glorify or vilify it.  We need a nationalism that finds a place for our legacy, the children and grand children of empire, one that gives them and us something to believe in - an identity that is strong enough to look past the colour of someone's skin or the god they pray to, an identity strong enough, that petty tribalism, backwardness and oppression in all their forms cannot stand against it and are dissipated by it. We need a national identity that holds no faith sacred. This is the only way to function in a multi-faith society in which no one spiritual leader or book may claim moral certainty. But secular opinion must also be challenged.  The man in the street must no longer hold sway.  There is a reason he does not run the country, let's not run it for him. This means leaders must grow a backbone and condemn white, black and brown wrong-headedness with the same vigour, whether it be motivated by religion, or run of the mill ignorance.

It is difficult to say whether the challenge of integration that Britain faces is as great or greater than that of France. Countries are big places, one city or village differs from the other. But the challenge is there either way, and history has taught us that national unity is only achievable in the face of a great cause. Could that cause not be to be better at integration than the French? They're already better at sex and cooking, so I for one, don't think we can let them have this. Could our great mission not be to discover and patent the model for functioning integrated societies in a globalised nation state in which traditional measures of identity are eroded? What would it be to have the British political model of integration implemented the world over? There might just be one or two in this faded imperial nation who would enjoy the symmetry of that.

Wednesday, 1 October 2014

How to train your zombie novel


Ok, time to come clean...

For years now, I have built a career upon being one of those bad-ass writers who will not write spec work.  Writer's block is not a thing.  You pay me in advance and in a currency of my choice.  You can crit my work -  go on, make my day, for I am not like other writers.  You cannot make me cry.  I am detached, analytical, my brain is a series of wheels and cogs. Sharp to the touch. I will analyse your ideas, harvest the things I can use from your critique, discard those I consider to be merely opinion as opposed to analysis.  I can do all these things because I have no emotional attachment to my work.  It is a collection of letters and phrases, each deliberate in its deployment for the singular purpose of meeting a remit, producing a product that behaves as it is supposed to.  I am a master of my craft and you will pay for my expertise.

And then I accidentally wrote a novel.

I say accidentally... it really was.  After the collapse of a particularly difficult film venture, the loss of 9 months of income, 12 months of endeavour and a lifetime of pride, it just seemed like the thing to do.  Nobody asked for it, nobody was expecting it, waiting to read it.  It was my secret and it became the receptacle for a sonic wave of anger, frustration, disappointment, but also hope, pride, political awakening and connection to a city, and in turn, for four of its imaginary denizens, their components plucked from people I have loved, feared, loathed and stood in awe of.

I did every single thing I teach my students not to.  I wrote without a plan.  I prioritised the work to the detriment of paid employment, regular meals and personal hygiene. (There is a dark corner of my couch that has seen some things)  My fiancé is still deeply mystified as to why I would seek that moment to expend that much energy when so much was at stake.  I couldn't stop.  I wrote without much understanding of the world of prose.  I was an interloper, charging across vast unknown plains of words and encountering precious little resistance.  2 thousand words per day, 3 thousand, 5...  It became something that consumed me, a punch bag inside my own head that I could unload upon.  And fuck it felt good...

Once I let the secret slip, good friends whispered wise words of caution as the word count approached 70, 80, 90 thousand.  The thing started to take shape.  Started to become something unexpected.  It had completely broken out of what weakened remit I had chained it with and was rampaging loose under its own momentum, savaging the things I was supposed to be doing, ripping out the throat of anything that threatened its reign of terror.

And then, one day it was done.

I couldn't look at it for almost a week, or much of anything else for that matter.  I left it to skulk, pad around, perhaps in the hope that it might of its own volition find a way out into the world that did not involve me at all.  But no.  It waited... with something almost resembling obedience.  It now had expectations of me that I would have to try to meet.

It felt like taking a rabid dog to the vet.  I coaxed it out from under the couch, ran my fingers through its grammar one last time in the hope of calming it before forcing it into the pet carrier of a 50 page sample and a synopsis that upon reflection was infinitely less revealing of its origins and purpose than this article.  Needless to say, it howled all the way there, scratching at its split infinitives which were becoming raw and infected.  It didn't matter.  It would soon be out of my hands and into those of the dreaded agent, whom I was hoping would be able to diagnose clean bill of health, and perhaps proscribe a sedative for us both.

For 12 days, I sat in the digital waiting room.  At first, it felt strange not to have it around.  It felt odd to watch occasional home improvement shows of an evening.  This is, it seems behaviour utterly incompatible with the life of a professional novelist, especially one bent on writing a whole novel in three months.  Even so, with it out of the house, I began to humanise again, began to eat and bathe regularly, began to work on writing jobs that pay actual money.  I had almost returned to pre-novel levels of paranoia and neurosis when the word came in.

My novel... my poor, angry, rabid, vibrant lurcher of a novel whilst otherwise reasonably healthy, if somewhat over written, had been diagnosed with a terminal case of literary fiction.  The saddest part was, it didn't seem any the wiser about its diagnosis.  If anything, it seemed pleased to see me, as if its poor undeveloped novel brain couldn't comprehend how ill it actually was.  At least it didn't appear to be in any pain.  Like all concerned owners without any real expertise in the area, I took to the internet in an attempt to better understand the diagnosis.

For the reference of anyone else who suffers a similar diagnosis, it is important to note the following.
1.  If one types 'literary fiction' into google, its search engine helpfully adds 'is dead' as item one in the auto-complete search bar.
2.  Most of the articles you then find date back to around 2010.  My poor savage beast was as Will Self puts it, a 'Stillborn novel', written by a misguided person intent on some sort of zombie necromancy.
3.  On the plus side, there is a new wave of articles entitled 'Literary fiction is dead articles are dead.' which would seem to indicate that so dead is literary fiction that even articles bemoaning its death are now also extinct.

The news was difficult to take.  For a while, I didn't want to give up.  I looked up radical new treatments of zombie literary fiction having some success in America.  New experimental interventions that might prolong the life of my novel.  For most, the research was still in its early stages and the techniques were not as yet approved for use by the Times Literary Supplement.  My heart sank.  The agent himself had only suggested two highly drastic possible treatments, both requiring intensive surgery and long periods of medication that might change the mood of my novel, alter its behaviour...  The first was to re-envisage it as a thriller, involving the removal of characters and an increase in plot driven narrative.  The second was more drastic.  It involved the forced neutering and reconstitution of my novel as a 'Young Adult' book...

I carefully mulled over all of these options.  Both were invasive and painful treatments, the second requiring an unrequited sexual tension that I thought would be hard for my novel to bare.  My first reaction was that in order to spare my novel any further pain, and though it would be very sad it might be kinder and easier on everyone concerned to self publish it down.  But it seemed wrong to do that to such a young book that was as yet unaware of its symptoms.  Instead, I decided that it could perhaps be retrained, to somehow make the leap from angry diatribe to something more universal.  (When you try to put 'commercial literary fiction' into google, nothing comes up.)  My novel did not seem to care.

So, with the rolled up newspaper of literary theory, the chew toy of genre identity, and a firm leash attached to its authorial voice, I am going to attempt to make it something more obedient, whilst at the same time, preserving something of the wild eyed savagery of its soul.  This will be a challenge, to be sure, but then if necromancy was easy, everybody would be doing it.

Or perhaps not...


Thursday, 18 September 2014

Decision Day



Decision Day

The road has been a long one but the day is finally here
A great delight of blue and white for all that hold it dear
A nation asked a question and an answer close at hand
We look inside our bravest hearts and take our final stand

I hate no man and dare to hope no man nor lass hates me
One Scot shall feel she’s ripped in half - another feels he’s free
But hope or fear one thing is clear – Our nation is awake
Let strength and pride and passion drive the choice that we must make.

Whatever warrior wins the day, that moment, there and then
We all must vow – no way, no how shall Scotland sleep again
Our future rests in our own hands, in all that we can give
Both Aye and Naw will work to build a place we’re proud to live

A Scot is not a person who lets bitterness succeed
A Scot does not define herself by malice, fear or greed
A Scot will fight and die until their cause be lost or won
A Scot forgives his foe the very day the battle’s done

I look upon my folk today - my heart swells up with pride
I see a dream that might come true, I see a dream denied
I wish I could be there with you as our people have their say
I send you all my love and hope on this decision day.



Nick Bain

A proud and hopeful Scot

Monday, 15 September 2014

Who Owns Scotland? A final post on Independence


As the countdown to THE VOTE enters its last exhausting phase, a nation is well and truly holding its breath.  My own family is divided on the subject, as are my friends.  None of these are people I would characterise as idiots - some are frighteningly intelligent in fact.

But there's something I've noticed in the last panicked, frantic week since the YouGov poll so terrified the Westminster parties.  My thinking on this matter has gone beyond the poll, beyond this one country.  The last week has led me to ask a question that uses Scotland as its test case but could be equally asked of the UK as a whole or any country that purports to hold itself to true democratic standards.

So who owns Scotland?  A space alien arriving in the last week might have leapt to some strange conclusions if they'd been held in a secret bunker and been forced to watch rolling news.

So here are some suggestions:

1.  Gordon Brown

In the heat of the poll shocks, a rather strange saviour appeared on the horizon - None other than Gordon Brown - the same entirely discredited figure lampooned for years in the British media and at least once a week at PMQs since his ignominious resignation post crash, post the end of boom and bust.  But maybe I'm wrong.  By dint of being 'the most famous Scottish politician' and therefore appealing to Scots because, in a fit of faultless logic, he's Scottish, Gordon rode in at the 11th hour to table the version of Devo-Max that was set to save the Union.  Gordon's ideas, far from being anything resembling national policy or any formal proposal were, in Gordon's own words, something he'd concocted in conversations with his own constituents - surely Kirkaldy's first non sheep related contribution to any national debate.  They did not, and do not, as far as I can work out, have even the support of the now leader of Gordon's own party.  They are a blueprint for constitutional change that has not been voted for, ratified or even discussed in either the Scottish or UK parliaments. And yet... they may form the basis of the future constitutional makeup of a United Kingdom in the event of a 'No' vote.  This is, as far as I can make out, extremely odd behaviour for a democratic country.

2.  The Markets

The markets are nervous.  The markets dislike uncertainty.  The markets will make Scotland suffer in the event of a Yes vote.  Alistair Darling and David Cameron are loathe to unsettle the markets, to upset them, to do anything that might make them respond negatively to the UK as a whole, never mind Scotland...  Who the **** are the markets?  Are talking about the movers and shakers of large scale capital and commercial investment?  Are we talking about 'big business'?  Are we talking about those who hold the largest slices of UK debt?  Are we talking about the financial operators and investment bankers whom the UK government just bailed out?  The great financial wizards that just about sunk their own version of capitalism only a handful of years ago?  There are a few terrifying questions here that need addressing.

A.  When did I elect the markets to act as guarantors and overseers of British or Scottish political policy?  Are we to consult the markets on all the democratic decisions we try to make within our political system?  Should I ask the markets to educate my children (Or in my case my cat), dictate our health service policy (The markets also dislike the NHS by the way - its a closed protectorate founded upon 'dangerous socialist principles'.  The market would seek to turn it into a private free for all, run for profit - should we do that too?)

B.  Given that the markets misgivings are in large part being solicited, encouraged and presented by elected UK politicians and not just random back benchers - the Prime Minister and leaders of the next two major parties (Such as we can still call the Lib Dems that), am I to assume that British politics is already largely in hock to big business and capital brokers - that our political system is little more than a multi-coloured layer of administration in which small arguments can be had but the same agenda is preserved?  Business in particular is not shy about its motivations.  It acts in its own interest, always.  This is why our country at least attempts to maintain the pretence of not being run as a PLC.

C.  Scottish Independence is no small matter of branding or PR.  It is real politics.  of course the markets don't like it.  They hate real politics in almost all its forms because we theoretically have a political system in which power ultimately lies with you and I.  There are few things that scare the markets, and indeed the politicians more than an 85% turnout for ANYTHING.  They would rather we kept our expressions of populism confined to X factor.  Genuine populist debate that could shake or redefine the comfortable status quo will not be popular with the markets.  they would rather have politicians who don't do anything and leave them to get on with things their way.  Speaking of which...

3.  The Leaders of the three Westminster political parties.  Westminster politics is a sickly beast right now.  We are led by a PR man for whom principles are something that less evolved beings worry about.  Cameron has backed down to big business on taxation, on alcohol minimum pricing, cigarette packaging and on the green incentives he championed and then withdrew from because it was hard.  he has no demonstrable political backbone and only takes any sort of stand where he perceives there will be a 100% chance of success.  Even then, he still misreads the political landscape as he did over Syria.  He has spectacularly misread the tone and quality of the debate in Scotland and has lacked both foresight and courage to meet the arguments head on.  He could have turned the whole thing into a damp squib by simply conceding to having Devo Max on the ballo
t paper - no independence - no cost to the better together campaign given they are supposed to support more powers.  (Funny how they weren't up for that one)

He is opposed by probably the weakest leader of the Labour Party in living memory (And even I can remember some pretty dreadful ones)  He has next to no personal charisma, no core group of labour voters with whom he has any resonance - too ineffectual to appeal to the liberal intellectulatte, too sheltered, pretentious and socially ignorant to have any presence with the core of working class Labour voters.  Too weak and close to the unions to win over the centre ground South.  I'm sure he is a really nice guy, but he can't deliver a coherent message to the point that his message regardless of its content can only be incoherence.

Then there's Nick Clegg...

It is interesting to note that UK politics is in such a state of turmoil that though a broadly unpopular right wing government is in coalition with a morally bankrupt centrist party, opposed by a centre leaning Labour Party.  In this climate, with its whole bias leaning right, only the UK could come up with UKIP, a party of protest TO THE RIGHT OF ALL OF THIS!

These people do not have the qualifications to dictate the terms of devo max to the people of Scotland from proposals drawn from thin air and carved up between them, without taking those terms to the House of Commons for approval.  They cannot do that of course because English MPS would use it as an opportunity to answer the West Lothian Question and seek to remove Scottish votes from English issues.  They are hugely opposed to what they perceive as another 'giveaway' to the Scots.  This is why I hope the answer to my question is in fact the below.

4.  You

Call me old fashioned, call me naive.  I still believe that the people of Scotland (And as an ex pat I sadly do not include myself in this) should be able to come to their own decision and for that decision to mean something.  This is about self determination at its most fundamental.  It is about redefining our relationship with our politics - to assume full accountability for the policies we chose to let define us.  We could linger on as the socially liberal corner of a UK that seems to regard our values with less and less respect, but where would that actually get us, would that galvanise a people with many gifts, many strengths and many problems to take some hard choices of our own.  A yes vote will not be a vote for an easy life.  It will be a vote to step onto the international stage and test our identity, culture and principles against the best and worst the world has to offer.  We will be empowered to build a country around the national conscience we pride in Scotland and be expected to defend and uphold its values in the world.  I think we can do it and once we are on the road to that, the markets, big business and even the UK's politicians (with luck new ones) will begin to see the opportunities that only a new country can present.

So when you all come to cast your vote, know that I am deeply jealous of your ability to properly take part, the chance you now have before you.  I ask nothing more than that you take your decision for the best possible reasons in a way that asserts the power of a people to determine their fate.  There is still some strength left in a galvanised people with the ambition to make a real difference, both inside and outside of their own country.

Take that chance, and there is nothing you cannot overcome.